Manual vs. Automatic Transmissions: Pros and Cons

Choosing between a manual and an automatic transmission can leave you at a crossroads. Manual transmission cars are far less common than vehicles with an automatic transmission, accounting for less than 2.5% of car sales in the United States. The decision between these two transmission types can significantly impact the driving experience, convenience, and overall satisfaction of owning a vehicle. In this article, we are going to take a look at some of the pros and cons of manual and automatic transmissions, helping you make an informed decision as to what is best for you and your next vehicle.

Understanding the Different Types of Transmissions

A car’s transmission is one of the most critical components of the vehicle. It’s what moves the power from the engine to the wheels, which in turn, rotates the wheels. To keep it simple, your transmission is what makes your wheels move and enables the gear ratio between the drive wheels and engine to adjust as the car slows down and speeds up. Before we jump into manual vs. automatic transmissions and the pros and cons, we wanted to provide an understanding as to what each of these types of transmissions is.

  • Manual Transmission: Vehicles with a manual transmission have a clutch pedal which unlocks the gears so you can safely shift from one gear into the next. With a manual transmission, the driver has to do the work to change gears and it is not involuntary like with an automatic transmission.
  • Automatic Transmission: An automatic transmission (sometimes abbreviated to auto or AT) is a multi-speed transmission used in motor vehicles that does not require any driver input to change gears, under normal driving conditions. Most drivers with an automatic transmission have little to no intervention with their transmission when it comes to shifting gears. An automatic transmission has no clutch pedal and once the transmission is in “drive”, everything is automatic.

We will stop there for now and get into what you came here for, the pros and cons of each.

Manual vs. Automatic Transmissions

Before choosing your next car, you need to decide whether you want a manual or automatic transmission. The big question is, which one is better? Both transmission types have unique advantages and disadvantages, depending on your personal driving habits, we break those down below.

Manual Transmissions:

Pros:

  • Control: The number one reason to choose a manual transmission, or stick shift, is that you like the feeling of being engaged with the car and the level of control it offers. Shifting gears manually allows drivers to have a more engaging driving experience. It provides a sense of connection with the vehicle, as you have direct control over gear changes, clutch engagement, and engine revs.
  • Lower Costs: Manual transmissions are generally simpler in design and have fewer components than automatic transmissions. This makes vehicles not only less expensive upfront to buy, but also translate into lower maintenance and repair costs over the lifetime of the vehicle.

Cons:

  • Harder to Learn: Operating a manual transmission requires a certain level of skill and coordination. If you’re not familiar with manual transmissions, there may be a learning curve involved. Compared to automatics, there is a lot more to think about when driving a manual car.
  • More Work: One of the key differences in manual vs. automatic transmissions is the effort you have to put in when driving. This is especially true in heavy traffic or stop-and-go situations, where the constant clutch engagement and gear changes can become tiring and inconvenient.  
  • Difficult to Find: In recent years, manual transmissions are becoming considerably less common. There are only a small percentage of vehicles made today that still offer a stick shift or manual option.

Automatic Transmissions:

Pros:

  • Ease of Use: Automatic transmissions are designed for simplicity and convenience. With no clutch pedal and the ability to change gears automatically, they are much easier to operate. You don’t need to concentrate on changing gears and operating the clutch, making this type of transmission popular for drivers who prioritize comfort and convenience.
  • Smoother Ride: Automatic transmissions are great at providing smooth and seamless gear shifts. The advanced technology and computer-controlled systems enable precise gear changes without any interruption in power delivery. This results in a comfortable and effortless driving experience.
  • More Options and Better Resale Value: Nearly every car in production in America has an automatic transmission version offered, meaning you have your choice of vehicles. Not to mentioned, when it comes time to sell or trade in your car, having an automatic transmission can make it easier to attract potential buyers and have a higher resale price.

Cons:

  • Higher Costs: Automatic transmissions generally come at a higher initial cost compared to manual transmissions. Additionally, if any repairs or maintenance are required, the complexity of automatic transmission systems can result in higher service bills.
  • Less Thrilling: This is subjective, but many people think that driving with an automatic transmission is boring and less exciting than its manual counterpart. Many drivers enjoy changing gears and like the connection and control it gives them to their vehicle.

Some studies have found that manual transmissions have better fuel efficiency than the automatic; however, with current technology, that seems to be changing, so we did not list that one above.

Both transmission types have their own set of pros and cons. When choosing between a manual and automatic transmission, the choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences, driving needs, and lifestyle.

Regardless of the type of transmission you have, when it comes to transmission repair, rebuilding, or remanufacturing, Advanced Transmissions & Emissions are your Phoenix transmission experts. We are a Phoenix full-service auto mechanic repair shop. If your check engine light is on, call us, we can do a diagnostic check while you wait. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Posted in

$100 Off All Major Repairs Mention Code: MJRREP

Offer Limited to Transmission and Engine Rebuilds Only

About Advanced Transmissions & Emissions
Contact Us

Name(Required)

Vehicle Details